Celtic may soon face a key defensive decision, with new signing Benjamin Arthur emerging as a potential challenger to Liam Scales after being likened to a “young Virgil van Dijk” by Dundee manager Steven Pressley.
The 20-year-old centre-back joined the Hoops on loan from Brentford on deadline day and, despite not yet making his debut, has already generated excitement at Parkhead following strong performances earlier this season.
Celtic escape SFA Cup scare
Celtic required a dramatic late turnaround to avoid elimination from the SFA Cup last weekend, with Junior Adamu’s stoppage-time equaliser forcing extra time against Dundee before Sebastian Tounekti sealed a 2–1 win.
However, the match also highlighted defensive concerns, particularly surrounding Liam Scales, whose positioning and lack of pressure contributed to Ethan Hamilton’s long-range opener for Dundee.
Concerns grow over Liam Scales’ form
Scales has struggled to replicate the consistency he showed during the 2024/25 campaign. His duel success rates have dropped significantly this season, winning just 49% of his ground duels in the Premiership, compared to 68% last term.
The Irish defender has also been loose in possession, surrendering the ball 30 times across his last three domestic and European appearances, increasing pressure on Martin O’Neill to consider alternatives at centre-back.
Who is Benjamin Arthur?
Benjamin Arthur arrived from Brentford with a reputation as a physically dominant defender. Steven Pressley, who previously worked with him at the Premier League club, described the youngster as a “huge unit” and compared him to a “young Virgil van Dijk” a notable reference given the Dutchman’s legacy at Celtic.
Arthur has limited senior experience, with just three first-team appearances, but his performances in the League Cup for Brentford this season offered encouragement.
Why Arthur could suit O’Neill’s system
In two League Cup starts against Aston Villa and Grimsby, Arthur won 73% of his duels and was not dribbled past once across 161 minutes. His physical presence, composure in possession and aerial strength suggest he could bring balance to Celtic’s back line.
Introducing a right-footed centre-back like Arthur would also allow Auston Trusty to operate on the left side of defence, his more natural position.
A genuine battle for places at Celtic
While comparisons to Virgil van Dijk may be premature, Arthur’s profile and early signs point to a defender capable of pushing for regular minutes. With Cameron Carter-Vickers expected to return next season, competition at centre-back is intensifying.
For Scales, the coming months could prove decisive as Celtic assess whether Arthur can provide a more secure and dynamic option at the heart of defence.
Thiago Nuno is a football editor and analyst covering European leagues, match statistics, and transfer market trends.
