Manchester United risks repeating mistakes with Garnacho and Mainoo, Ten Hag sends warning to Amorim

Manchester United could be on the verge of repeating a familiar error by considering the departures of Alejandro Garnacho and Kobbie Mainoo, two young talents developed at the club. Manager Erik ten Hag has reportedly sent a warning to Ruben Amorim, emphasizing the risk of letting promising players leave, recalling the recent case of Scott McTominay, who is now a standout performer at Napoli after leaving Old Trafford.
Ten Hag’s Message
The Dutch coach, who handed Mainoo his professional debut, described him in 2024 as a “perfect midfielder.” He has also praised Garnacho, highlighting the Argentine’s attacking contributions, with 21 goals over the last two seasons, and signaling his potential to reach world-class status.
Ten Hag fears that losing these talents prematurely could harm Manchester United’s long-term prospects, particularly as the team struggles for offensive output.
Current Situation of the Players
Mainoo, 20, has struggled for game time under Amorim in the Premier League and reportedly sought a move to Napoli, which Manchester United blocked. Garnacho has been offered a deal by Chelsea and has been training separately since December due to internal concerns, including alleged leaks of tactical information.
Despite the challenges, both players remain highly sought after, attracting interest from top clubs across Europe. Supporters worry that the board could repeat the mistake of selling McTominay for under €30 million (R$190.5 million), a player recently voted the best in Serie A.
Fan Concerns
On social media, fans have voiced strong criticism of a potential deal sending Garnacho to Chelsea, valued around £40 million (R$292.8 million). With Manchester United’s attack already struggling for goals, losing their third-highest recent scorer is seen as a risky move.
With the transfer window closing soon, Mainoo’s stay at Old Trafford appears more likely, while Garnacho could leave in the coming days if negotiations with Chelsea advance.