Should Barcelona Sign a Right-Back This Summer? Evaluating the Options for Hansi Flick
Barcelona’s 2025 summer transfer window continues to buzz with speculation, and while much of the attention has been focused on the attack with Nico Williams nearing a move there’s one area that remains notably thin: right-back.
Despite Jules Koundé featuring in almost every game last season, playing more minutes than any defender aside from Pau Cubarsí, it’s important to remember that Koundé is a natural centre-back. His adaptation to the right side has been commendable, but it’s not a long-term solution.
A Squad Thin on Right-Backs
With Héctor Fort as the only natural right-back available, and still just 18 years old, Barcelona lack serious depth in that position. An injury to Koundé would leave Flick’s squad dangerously exposed a problem that was evident at times during the 2024/25 campaign.
The Options: Cancelo, Pubill, or Vanderson?
João Cancelo (€12–15M)
- Age: 31
- Club: Manchester City (loaned to Barça last season)
- Pros: Knows the club, experienced, strong in attack
- Cons: Defensive lapses, high salary, short-term solution
Cancelo is the “safe” option due to his familiarity with the squad and style of play. However, Barcelona must ask if investing in a 31-year-old prone to mistakes is the wisest use of funds during a tight financial window.
Marc Pubill (Almería)
- Age: 22
- Estimated Fee: €10–12M
- Pros: U21 Spain standout, Barcelona native, long-term option
- Cons: Less top-level experience
Pubill impressed during the U21 European Championship, showing both composure and technical skill under pressure. Given his youth and potential resale value, he could be a smart investment for the futur and he ticks the box of developing Spanish talent.
Vanderson (Monaco)
- Age: 24
- Estimated Fee: €40M
- Pros: Stronger pedigree, experience at elite level
- Cons: Expensive, Monaco unlikely to lower price
While Vanderson offers immediate quality and experience, Barcelona’s financial constraints make a €40M move nearly impossible without major sales. He’s the best player on the list but arguably the least realistic.
The Verdict: Yes, But Be Smart
There’s no doubt: Barcelona must sign a right-back this summer. Koundé can’t carry the burden alone, and the risk of burnout or injury is too great. But it must be a strategic signing, not a flashy one.
Ideal Scenario
- Marc Pubill emerges as the most sensible target affordable, talented, local, and long-term.
- If Barcelona wants an immediate solution, Cancelo on a low-cost deal might suffice as a one-season stopgap.
