Kevin O’Toole Family: Fiancée, Children, Parents and Siblings

Last Updated on September 14, 2026 by Wilson

Kevin O’Toole is an American-born professional footballer who plays as a left-back and wing-back for New York City FC. His full name is Kevin William Nathaniel O’Toole, and he was born on December 14, 1998.

Kevin comes from a family with strong connections to football and Ireland. His parents are Eric and Nancy O’Toole, while his siblings, Jillian and Patrick, have also played NCAA Division I soccer. Kevin is engaged to his longtime girlfriend, Emma Davis.

Who Is Kevin O’Toole’s Girlfriend?

Kevin O’Toole’s longtime partner is Emma Davis. However, she should now be described as his fiancée rather than simply his girlfriend.

Kevin and Emma became engaged during 2025. New York City FC later confirmed the engagement in an official feature about the defender’s eventful year.

The couple are planning to marry in Ireland in June 2027. The choice of Ireland has special significance because Kevin’s paternal family has Irish roots, and his late grandfather was originally from Dún Laoghaire, County Dublin.

Emma supported Kevin when he received his first call-up to the Republic of Ireland senior squad in November 2025. Reports indicated that she travelled to Ireland alongside members of the O’Toole family.

Information about Emma’s profession, education and personal background has not been widely published. She generally maintains a private profile despite her relationship with a professional footballer.

Does Kevin O’Toole Have Children?

As of now, there is no reliable public information indicating that Kevin O’Toole has children.

Kevin and Emma have announced their engagement and future wedding plans, but they have not publicly announced the birth of a son or daughter. Reports about their relationship have also not described them as parents.

Who Are Kevin O’Toole’s Parents?

Kevin O’Toole’s parents are Eric O’Toole and Nancy O’Toole. Both parents have supported the football careers of Kevin and his siblings.

The family spent approximately two years living in Poland when Kevin was in first and second grade. That experience proved important because Kevin joined his first organised football team while living there.

Kevin has said that travelling through Europe and experiencing its football culture helped him develop his love for the sport. After the family returned to the United States, he continued his development before joining the New York Red Bulls academy.

Who Is Kevin O’Toole’s Father?

Kevin’s father is Eric O’Toole. His family’s Irish heritage comes through Eric’s side.

Kevin has explained that his father has always been proud of his Irish ancestry and encouraged his children to understand their family’s connection to the country. That influence became particularly meaningful when Kevin was invited to represent the Republic of Ireland.

In 2025, Eric reportedly began a new professional position in California. Further details about his occupation have not been widely disclosed.

Who Is Kevin O’Toole’s Mother?

Kevin’s mother is Nancy O’Toole, formerly Nancy Reinisch. She was an accomplished footballer before her children entered the sport.

Nancy played at Manalapan High School in New Jersey before representing the College of William & Mary. Her experience as a college athlete gave Kevin and his siblings a parent who understood the demands of combining education with competitive football.

Nancy’s former William & Mary teammate Julie Shackford later became a college coach. That connection helped introduce Kevin to the Princeton University football programme when he was young.

Kevin eventually attended Princeton, where he became a two-time Ivy League Player of the Year and a United Soccer Coaches First-Team All-American.

Who Are Kevin O’Toole’s Siblings?

Kevin O’Toole has two known siblings: a sister named Jillian O’Toole and a brother named Patrick O’Toole. Football has played an important role in all three siblings’ lives.

Jillian O’Toole

Jillian O’Toole is a midfielder who played college soccer for William & Mary, the same university represented by her mother.

She later moved to Ireland and joined Treaty United in the League of Ireland Women’s Premier Division. Jillian became an important member of the club and served as its captain.

Her career in Ireland strengthened the family’s relationship with the country. Kevin visited Ireland to watch Jillian play before receiving his own opportunity with the national team.

Patrick O’Toole

Patrick O’Toole is Kevin’s younger brother. He played NCAA Division I soccer at the University of Michigan.

Like Kevin and Jillian, Patrick grew up playing football and pursued the sport at the university level. This means that all three O’Toole siblings reached NCAA Division I soccer, while Kevin and Jillian subsequently played professionally.

The O’Toole Siblings’ Football Project

Kevin, Jillian and Patrick established a family project called Athlete’s Toole Box. The initiative helps young footballers and their families understand the college recruitment process in the United States.

The siblings use their combined experiences in academy, college and professional football to guide aspiring players. Their project reflects the role that education and sport have played within the O’Toole family.

Kevin O’Toole’s Irish Grandfather

Kevin qualified to represent the Republic of Ireland through his paternal grandfather, Eric O’Toole, who was born in Dún Laoghaire, County Dublin.

His grandfather emigrated to the United States in 1958 and started a family there. He died in 2001, shortly before Kevin’s third birthday.

Despite never having the opportunity to know him well, Kevin has spoken about honouring his grandfather’s memory by representing Ireland. The family maintained its connection to its Irish heritage through Kevin’s father and regular visits to the country.

Frequently Asked Questions About Kevin O’Toole’s Family

Is Kevin O’Toole married?

Kevin O’Toole is not yet married. He is engaged to Emma Davis, and the couple plan to marry in Ireland in June 2027.

Who is Kevin O’Toole’s fiancée?

His fiancée is Emma Davis, his longtime girlfriend.

Does Kevin O’Toole have children?

No reliable source has reported that Kevin O’Toole has children.

Who are Kevin O’Toole’s parents?

His parents are Eric and Nancy O’Toole.

Did Kevin O’Toole’s mother play football?

Yes. Nancy O’Toole played college soccer at William & Mary after starring at Manalapan High School.

Does Kevin O’Toole have siblings?

Yes. He has a sister named Jillian and a brother named Patrick. Both have played NCAA Division I soccer.

Who is Kevin O’Toole’s Irish grandfather?

His paternal grandfather was Eric O’Toole, a native of Dún Laoghaire who emigrated to the United States in 1958.