When Birmingham City splashed over £15m on Jay Stansfield in 2024, it was the ultimate statement of intent. The gamble paid off: Stansfield’s 19 goals fired the Blues out of League One and, in 2026, has them dreaming of a return to the Premier League. However, as the top flight beckons, a sobering reality is emerging Birmingham may have sold their most “Premier League-ready” star two years ago for a fraction of Stansfield’s price.
While Stansfield remains the poster boy of the new era, Jordan James sold to Rennes for just £4m is currently proving at Leicester City that he is the one truly destined for the elite level.
The Stansfield Struggle: Physicality Concerns
There is no denying Stansfield’s output. With 9 goals and 10 big chances created this season, he is the heartbeat of the Blues’ attack. Yet, the statistics reveal a worrying trend for a player eyeing the top tier. Much like Joel Piroe’s struggles at Leeds, Stansfield is finding the physical battle in the Championship grueling.
The “Piroe” Parallel (2025/26 Championship):
- Ground Duel Success: Just 28% (Stansfield)
- Aerial Duel Success: A staggering 11% (Stansfield)
The Risk: Premier League defenders are notoriously more physical; on current evidence, Stansfield could be “dominated” in the top flight, lacking the frame to hold up play when goals dry up.
Jordan James: The Midfield “Standout”
In contrast, Jordan James has flourished since his return to England. On loan at Leicester from Rennes, the 21-year-old Welsh international has matched Stansfield’s goal tally (9) from central midfield with every single one coming from open play.
Stansfield vs. James (Head-to-Head 25/26):
- Goals: Both on 9.
- Pass Accuracy: James leads with 82% vs Stansfield’s 68%.
- Physicality: James wins 40% of his duels, nearly double Stansfield’s success rate.
Dubbed a “standout” by journalist Josh Bunting during his initial rise at St. Andrew’s, James has evolved into a powerhouse. He offers the goal-scoring threat of a striker with the tactical discipline and physical “steel” of a Premier League veteran.
The Verdict: A Bitter-Sweet Evolution
Birmingham’s decision not to stand in James’ way during their League One stint was noble, but it may have cost them a generational talent. While Stansfield is the hero who led the promotion charge, James is the athlete who looks built for the top-flight grind.
As the Blues push for the play-offs, they will rely on Stansfield’s magic. But watching Jordan James dominate the Championship for Leicester serves as a reminder: sometimes the biggest talents are the ones you let go for a bargain.
Siara Costa is a football editor and writer covering both European men’s and women’s football, with a focus on league competitions, match coverage, and in-depth storytelling.
